New 17" rim - should we get them in S-Body fitment?

[Evilchap]

These arrived today in BMW fitment - they'll be great on the E36...

But do you think we should get some for the S-Body as as well?

http://images.rotawheelsuk.com/rarerims/Wheels/images/d154178.5gunmetal.jpg
http://images.rotawheelsuk.com/rarerims/Wheels/images/d154178.5silver.jpg
http://images.rotawheelsuk.com/rarerims/Wheels/images/d154178.5white.jpg

[GarageSR]

IMHO....no. Maybe in a 4 stud for S12 but realistically how many would sell. Just my opinion, other opinions are available :D

[Evilchap]

I was half thinking on a low S13 with the right offset they could look good... but there again, what I like nobody else tends to, so you could well have a point :D

S12s aren't going to buy 17s, there aren't many out there either :(

[sparky_s13]

I like them, think they would look cool on the right styled s14a even

[dukey]

Really not sure about that. What sort of offsets do they come in ?

[Oreos]

Remind me of the old style touring car wheels. Wouldn't look right on an S-body imo

[snops]

If they were dished rather than pokey outey they'd be smart.

[Evilchap]

The face is flat to the lip, it doesn't poke out if that helps?

[Chriscooke]

Don't think it'll sell in 5x114 for any jap car :(

Would work well for German cars I expect

[shikari chaos]

Nope for the same reasons as stated. Could work well on bmws and the odd ford but not s body imo

[bennyboy]

I agree with the above but do think would look cool on a s12

[dukey]

Haha. Thread denied. Love it.

[Evilchap]

Haha. Thread denied. Love it.

Some would say denied. Others tidied. All I know is, I changed the record :D

[jbsauce]

Don't suit an s chassis.

*Edited by Rarerims - jbsauce is a bit of a broken record. He also apparently wont be buying any wheels, which we're sorry to hear, but we cant win them all :)

[Evilchap]

Thanks for all of the feedback everybody :) That's probably all we need to know. :)