Thanks for the input guys, i have ruled out diesel. My ibiza wasnt even warm when i got 1/2 way to work and in the winter was an issue with defrosting and not getting any good mpg.
I wouldnt really want to go down the BMW route personally. Not really a fan of them.
I do enjoy driving in general and i do have some decent roads near me which are fun for a little blast so a S15 would be the least boat like out the box.
My night shift commute home is lovely normally as well as not much traffic.
Auto TT soarer or aristo are defo my top 2 then s15. Im looking to be self maintaining these as well. I know the 2JZ oil filter is in a bitch of a place to get to as well.
I would probably end up doing a few bits to whatever car i get.
Appreciate all the input